Pizza · $
3 1st Ave, Raritan, NJ
Brick-oven pizzeria on First Avenue in Raritan that grew out of the bread bakery Costanio DeLucia opened there in 1917; pizza joined the menu in the 1930s, and same-day orders can mean a wait of hours. Giancarlo Stanton stopped in during his 2025 rehab stint with Double-A Somerset.